In this essay, I will lay out an argument for Jewish universalism, but before I begin building the argument, it is important to define our terms. Universalism can have a variety of meanings, but for the purposes of this paper, I will emphasize four somewhat related meanings. First is the concept that truth is applicable to all people. This includes metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical truth claims. Second is the inclusion and welcome of all people in a community, regardless of their ethnic or religious background. Third is tolerance and respect for other religious and ethnic communities. Fourth is the idea of universal salvation, the belief that no people are punished in hell forever. This fourth meaning originally emerged in Christianity, but I believe that it can also legitimately be held by faithful Jews. In fact, it is explicitly taught by my tradition: Jewish Science, which holds that all human beings are emanations of the Divine and will return to the Divine Source when they die.
The idea of universalism is often contrasted with particularism, the belief that Judaism is primarily concerned with Jews. While it is undeniable that Judaism makes distinctions between Israel (the Jewish people) and the other nations, it is also true that the distinction is made primarily to demonstrate the path of holiness. In other words, Judaism exists to elevate the Jews to be an example for all humanity, a “light to the nations” and a “kingdom of priests” (Isa. 42:6, Ex. 19:6). This outward focus for the particularity of Judaism shows that particularism is only meant to be in service of universalism. An exclusionary, ethnocentric attitude is antithetical to our purpose as Jews.
Theological Reasons
The unity of God implies, in fact requires, universalism. If the central claim of Judaism is true, that there is only one God who created all things and made humanity in his image, then God is the God of all people whether they worship him or not. In fact, this idea is central to traditional Jewish theology which teaches that God made a covenant with all human beings through Adam and Noah. This is typically referred to as the Noahide Covenant and consists of seven basic laws, which have been extrapolated out to a variety of different laws: 1) No idolatry; 2) No blasphemy; 3) No murder; 4) No sexual immorality (adultery, incest, bestiality); 5) No theft; 6) Do not eat the limb of a living animal; and 7) Establish courts of justice.
The Noahide laws are applicable to all human beings, were incorporated into the Jewish covenant with God, and there is an explicit understanding that non-Jews living in a Jewish society would be required to abide by them. This basic covenant with humanity is the heart of Jewish teaching: the unity of God and ethical behavior towards all people. But the concept of the Noahide covenant was created by the Rabbis; the Torah goes even further in its inclusion of non-Jews in the Jewish community.
The Torah itself tells us in a number of places that we are to love the ger as ourselves, which includes both resident aliens and converts to Judaism, and that there must be one law for everyone in a Jewish society (Ex. 12:48-49; Lev. 19:33-34, 24:22; Num. 15:14-16). The examples provided here point to the inclusion of non-Jews in the religious community and equality under the civil and criminal law. Natives are not given special treatment, and immigrants are not prejudiced. Everyone is included in the community as equals.
The example given above from Exodus is of particular interest. This passage is concerned with who is able to offer a Passover sacrifice. The Torah explicitly includes the gerim as eligible so long as the males undergo circumcision beforehand. This raises the question of conversion. Within the context, it is not at all clear if they are becoming Israelites (converting to Judaism), or if it is some other consideration that requires circumcision. It very well could be seen as entering the covenant of Abraham, but what about people like the Ishmaelites who are definitely not considered part of the Israelite nation even though they were included in the Abrahamic covenant (Gen. 17:10, 25)? The idea that circumcision would bring non-Israelites into the Israelite nation is not clear in this passage. It may simply be a matter of ritual purity or status. But the most important element is that God is including non-Israelites in the sacrifice meant to commemorate the redemption of the Israelite people from slavery. The most particularist Jewish celebration is inaugurated with a commandment to include eligible non-Jews.
I see this radical inclusion as a model for how a universalist Judaism can include non-Jews while remaining faithful to Judaism. The idea of universalism does not imply that anything goes. To the contrary, it is the idea that truth is singular and applies to all people, and for that reason people who seek to participate in the Jewish community must comply with the teachings and standards of Judaism. This is no different from any other universalist religion like Christianity, Islam, or Buddhism which similarly welcome all people without compromising their principles.
There are further doctrines and texts from Jewish tradition that support a universalist position. As already mentioned, the idea of human beings made in the image of God points to our essential equality. The Mishnah further teaches that God created Adam as the sole progenitor of humanity so that none could boast that their ancestral line was greater than anyone else’s (Mishnah 4:5). In addition, we learn from the prophets and the Psalms that God is the judge of all the earth and the Father of us all (e.g. Ps. 96:10, Mal. 2:10). Because God is the judge of all nations, not just of Israel, we can infer that God has ethical and religious expectations of these nations (i.e. a covenant) as we discussed above. The essential truth of Judaism, ethical monotheism, is therefore incumbent upon all people.
Israel’s Mission
But obviously, everyone does not adhere to ethical monotheism, which brings us to the next element of a universalist understanding of Judaism. Israel was chosen to bring the world to the worship of God. This can be seen in a number of places, beginning with Abraham, the first Jew.
The Sages present Abraham as the first person to recognize the unity of God and as a missionary who spread this truth to all who would listen. Indeed, the beloved stories of Abraham’s time in the idol shop of his father demonstrate his missionary zeal. He was not content to have merely discovered the futility of idolatry and the truth of monotheism; he needed to share it with everyone. Even his journey from Haran to Canaan was seen as a missionary journey, and his generous hospitality often had the ulterior motive of converting travelers to this religious truth. Nor was proselytism constrained to Abraham but also included Sarah and his descendants.[1]
We know the essence of Abraham’s teaching from the book of Genesis. When God is preparing to destroy Sodom and Gomorrah, he says to himself, “all the nations of the earth will find blessing through him. Indeed, I have known him in order that he may charge his sons and his household after him: they shall keep the way of Hashem, to do what is right and just” (18:18-19). In short, ethical monotheism and outreach to all nations is the core of Abraham’s message as a prophet. We can see from this that while one family was chosen to act as the messenger of the divine truth, it was a truth intended for all people. In fact, Abraham confirms this when he cries out, “The judge of all the earth—will he not do what is just?” (18:25).
The idea of God as the judge of the earth is found throughout the prophets, but perhaps the best example is the book of Jonah. Jonah is called to bring a message of repentance to the city of Nineveh, capital of the Assyrian empire, which he famously refuses to do at first. Only after God makes escape impossible does Jonah agree to head to Nineveh to fulfill his mission. He is successful in calling the Ninevites to repentance and the judgment of God is averted. Rather than finding joy in his success, Jonah is angry because the Ninevites are the enemies of Israel; Jonah wanted to see them punished. God’s message of universal care and concern for all people, even the enemies of his chosen people, further demonstrates the universalist character of Judaism.
Likewise, the book of Ruth contains a subversive message of radical inclusion for all people. As a Moabite, Ruth should have been prohibited from “entering the assembly of Hashem” (Deut. 23:4), yet she was allowed to marry Israelite men and is popularly seen as the first convert to Judaism. (The Rabbis argued that the prohibition was for male Moabites, not female, but this is not a convincing argument.) Even more impressive is the manner in which she “converts.” She does not follow anything like a typical process as it would later develop in Judaism but rather converts herself through acclamation while traveling with her mother-in-law Naomi. Her faithful loving-kindness to Naomi is rewarded with a new marriage that leads to her becoming the ancestor of King David and the future Messiah. The overriding message of the book of Ruth is that inclusion, mercy, and loving-kindness bring about redemption.
And of course, the book of Isaiah portrays Israel as a “light to the nations” (42:6). The light that Israel is meant to bring is described in the text: to open blind eyes, free prisoners, bring justice to the nations, and preach the unity of God (Isa. 42). The book of Isaiah continues in this line of thinking by describing a future in which God reigns and all on earth worship him. In chapter 45:21-22, God proclaims his unity and his nature as a redeemer, calling all nations to come and worship him. Chapter 49:6 declares that the light for the nations (Israel) is for the purpose of extending God’s salvation to the ends of the earth. Chapter 56:3-8 promises the foreigners who have joined themselves to God that they will be given a place in the house of God. Verse 7 of this section famously declares that God’s house will be “a house of prayer for all peoples.” And the concluding message of Isaiah is a vision of a time when all humanity will come to worship God in Jerusalem (Isa. 66:23).
Similarly, Zechariah 2:15 sees a time when the nations will join themselves to God, and God will take them as his people. Further in Zechariah, he describes a time when 10 men will grab the corners of a Jewish man’s clothes and plead to come with him to Jerusalem to worship God (8:22-23). Indeed, the conclusion of the book looks to a time when all the nations will be required to worship God in Jerusalem and celebrate Sukkot (Zech. 14:16-19).
This list of examples is far from exhaustive, but it demonstrates that Judaism is properly speaking a universalist tradition. It is a religion meant for all people because at the core of Judaism is the belief in unity: the unity of God and the unity of all humanity as the children of God. The emphasis on unity is so important that Rabbi Yohanan said, “Anyone who repudiates idolatry is called a Jew” (BT Megillah 13a). The separations between Israel and the nations that were prescribed in the Torah and expounded in Jewish tradition were meant only to ensure the survival and purity of the message. In a world overrun by idolatry, and Israelites who easily lapsed into the worship of idols, it was necessary to emphasize the distinctions between Israel and the nations, between the worship of God and the worship of idols. However, Judaism was never meant to be a religion that was closed off to outsiders. Rather, it was meant to be a light to the other nations, an example for them, and in fact a missionary religion following in the footsteps of Abraham, bringing all humanity to the worship of God.
So then, why has Judaism developed into a religion that does not proselytize and historically discouraged conversion? Why did the Jewish community become insular? The answer is that it was an accident of history. The rise of Christianity and Islam made conversion to Judaism dangerous for both the convert and the Jewish community. Both Christianity and Islam criminalized conversion to Judaism and brutally subjugated and occasionally persecuted Jews. The only way to survive was for the Jewish community to be unobtrusive and compliant with the dominant powers, which meant discouraging conversion and a suspicion of non-Jews. The missionizing practices and openness to gentile participation (without conversion) of the Second Temple period ceased for the sake of survival.
Reform Judaism and Jewish Universalism
The rise of the modern period with the emancipation of the Jews has reinvigorated the universalist elements of Judaism, although in a manner that is haphazard and inconsistent. Cultural inertia, reactionary Orthodoxy, and the continued scourge of antisemitism have made the embrace of universalism slow. The modern movement that has most consistently embraced universalism is American Reform Judaism. From its beginning, the American Reform Movement has emphasized Jewish universalism.
The Pittsburgh Platform of 1885[2] accepted every religion as a legitimate attempt to “grasp the Infinite,” and saw the modern era as the approaching Messianic hope of God’s kingdom on earth. The Platform went on to extend the hand of fellowship to all likeminded people who strove for righteousness and expressed a concern for social justice for all. It also affirms the immortality of the soul and rejects the doctrines of heaven, hell, and resurrection, seeing the human soul as divine and that it returns to God at death. These values and doctrines continued throughout all subsequent platforms and statements of principles.
The Columbus Platform of 1937 declared that Judaism’s message was universal and that all were welcome. They identified Israel’s mission to be a witness to the nations and emphasized the kinship of humanity. Like the Pittsburgh Platform, they called for social justice and expressed hope for universal peace.
The Centenary Perspective of 1976, coming after the Holocaust, was less enthusiastic about universalism and reflected a turn inward to Jewish particularism. But even here, the statement affirms that all people are made in the divine image and that Jews have both universal and particular obligations to others.
The latest statement of principles from 1999 shows a return to emphasizing universalism. It declared that the Torah is a manifestation of God’s love for Israel and all humanity, embraced religious pluralism, and promoted inclusion as a major value of Reform Judaism. Unlike the statements that came before it, the ’99 statement also incorporated a statement advocating for a soft form of proselytizing, building on the Outreach Program created by Rabbi Alexander Schindler.[3]
As an outgrowth of the Reform Movement, Jewish Science has adopted these universalist values. While we are firmly rooted in Jewish tradition, we are open to the participation of non-Jews and welcome all people in our communities as equals. Our theology actually requires universalism. We believe that God is present in all people; we are all innately connected to God because our souls are emanations of God. Recognizing God’s Presence in all creation naturally requires love and openness to all of God’s creatures, especially other human beings.
In addition to Reform Judaism and Jewish Science, there is a new movement explicitly taking on the name of Jewish Universalism.[4] It was begun by Rabbi Steven Blane and is the guiding philosophy of his congregation Sim Shalom and the Jewish Spiritual Leaders Institute, which trains Universalist rabbis.
These organizations ensure the continued influence of Jewish universalism and uphold the prophetic tradition of spreading the knowledge of God to everyone. In addition to the importance of sharing our faith with all nations, the prophets warned against parochialism and chauvinism (e.g. Amos 9:7ff, Jer. 7:4). It is not enough to simply focus on oneself or to have pride in a Jewish identity. Our duty is to be a light and blessing to the nations, which necessarily involves welcoming them into our communities and teaching them the truths of Judaism: that God is one and the true worship of God requires doing what is right and just. This is what we pray for everyday with the Aleinu, when God will rule over all the earth and all will recognize the unity of God. Hillel said it best, “Be among the disciples of Aaron…loving people and bringing them to the study of Torah” (Pirkei Avot 1:12).
[1] Proselytism In the Talmudic Period by Bernard Bamberger, 1939 Hebrew Union College Press, pages 175-180
[2] https://www.ccarnet.org/rabbinic-voice/platforms/
[3] https://urj.org/rabbi-schindler-1978-speech-establishing-outreach
Leave a Reply